Member store of the Premier Group member store

Member of the Premier Group

Get FREE CURBSIDE PICKUP on any order!

Toggle Nav

Maple Rd

3904 Maple Road
Amherst, NY 14226
Ph: 716-877-3574

Galleria Mall

1 Galleria Drive
Cheektowaga, NY 14225
Ph: 716-807-1122

  • Sign In
  • Create an Account
My Cart
Menu
Account
Search
Advanced Search
Curbside and In-Store Pickup Orders

Get FREE curbside pickup on any order! Orders are typically taking 2+ business hours to complete at this time. Please wait for an email confirming that your order is ready before coming to the store.

The Kitchen is Now Open: Order Online!

NOW OPEN! The Kitchen is open with an exciting new menu! Choose from artisanal flat-bread pizzas, crisp, refreshing salads, and hearty gourmet sandwiches, all made with the finest ingredients. VIEW MENU and ORDER ONLINE

Shop Premier Gourmet Gift Baskets

Our beautifully-arranged gift baskets are packed with the finest foods you'll find anywhere. Choose from a variety of baskets at various price points! SHOP GOURMET GIFT BASKETS

Shop Craft Beer at Premier Gourmet

With over 2,000 beers in stock, 20 premium beers on tap at our growler station, and a 'world-class' rating from Beer Advocate, we're Western New York's craft beer destination. SHOP CRAFT BEER

Premier Gourmet Meat & Cheese Charcuterie Trays

NEW! Our new meat and cheese charcuterie trays make entertaining easy! You choose from a selection of some of our finest meats and cheeses, and we'll do all the slicing and arranging. BUILD YOUR CHARCUTERIE TRAY

Mustards

View as Grid List

Items 1-15 of 57

Set Descending Direction
Narrow Your Search
Shopping Options
Manufacturer
  1. Arbor Hill 2items
  2. Beaverton Foods 6items
  3. Brownwood Farms 3items
  4. Colman's of Norwich 1item
  5. Kozlik's 1item
  6. Lakeshore 3items
  7. Lowensenf 2items
  8. McCormick & Co. 1item
  9. Merle 2items
  10. Nance's 2items
  11. Pommery 5items
  12. Sabatino Tartufi 1item
  13. Sierra Nevada Brewing Co 2items
  14. Stonewall Kitchen 4items
  15. Terrapin Farms 3items
  16. Unilever 3items
  17. Weber's 10items
  18. Woeber's Mustard Co. 3items
  19. World Finer Foods 2items
Less
  1. Amora - French Strong Dijon Mustard / 15.5 oz.
    Amora - French Strong Dijon Mustard / 15.5 oz.
    Limited Inventory

    -7 items or less in stock. We will confirm your order by email.

    $3.99
    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  2. Lakeshore - Whole Grain Mustard with Irish Stout / 7.23 oz.
    Lakeshore - Whole Grain Mustard with Irish Stout / 7.23 oz.
    $3.99
    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  3. Lakeshore - Wholegrain Mustard with Irish Whiskey / 7.23 oz.
    Lakeshore - Wholegrain Mustard with Irish Whiskey / 7.23 oz.
    $3.99
    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  4. Pommery - Mustard from Meaux (Moutarde de Meaux Pommery) / 17.6 oz.
    Pommery - Mustard from Meaux (Moutarde de Meaux Pommery) / 17.6 oz.
    Limited Inventory

    1 items or less in stock. We will confirm your order by email.

    $19.99
    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  5. Weber's - Horseradish Mustard / 16 oz. jar
    Weber's - Horseradish Mustard / 16 oz. jar
    Local Item

    Locally-Made Item

    This item cannot be shipped. It's available for local delivery and in-store pickup only

    Not Shippable. WNY Local Delivery and In-Store Pickup only. Learn More Sorry, this item is not available for shipment outside of the Western New York area. We do not ship certain items due to their size, weight, packaging, or due to difficulties with keeping certain perishable items fresh during transit.

    Limited Inventory

    -86 items or less in stock. We will confirm your order by email.

    $2.79
    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  6. Brownwood Farms - Famous Kream Mustard / 10 oz.
    Brownwood Farms - Famous Kream Mustard / 10 oz.
    Limited Inventory

    4 items or less in stock. We will confirm your order by email.

    $6.99
    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  7. Woeber's Champagne Dill Mustard 5 OZ
    Woeber's Champagne Dill Mustard 5 OZ
    Limited Inventory

    3 items or less in stock. We will confirm your order by email.

    $1.99
    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  8. Inglehoffer Creamy Dill Mustard 4 OZ
    Inglehoffer Creamy Dill Mustard 4 OZ
    $1.99
    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  9. Terrapin Ridge Farms Garlic Kraut Mustard 10.5 oz
    Terrapin Ridge Farms Garlic Kraut Mustard 10.5 oz
    $6.49
    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  10. Weber's - Horseradish Mustard Squeeze Jar / 12 oz.
    Weber's - Horseradish Mustard Squeeze Jar / 12 oz.
    Local Item

    Locally-Made Item

    This item cannot be shipped. It's available for local delivery and in-store pickup only

    Not Shippable. WNY Local Delivery and In-Store Pickup only. Learn More Sorry, this item is not available for shipment outside of the Western New York area. We do not ship certain items due to their size, weight, packaging, or due to difficulties with keeping certain perishable items fresh during transit.

    $3.19
    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  11. Arbor Hill Brew & Brats Beer Mustard
    Arbor Hill Brew & Brats Beer Mustard
    Limited Inventory

    1 items or less in stock. We will confirm your order by email.

    $6.99
    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  12. Brownwood Farms - Golden Ale Mustard / 10 oz.
    Brownwood Farms - Golden Ale Mustard / 10 oz.
    $6.99
    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  13. Brownwood Farms - Kickin' Kream Mustard / 10 oz.
    Brownwood Farms - Kickin' Kream Mustard / 10 oz.
    $6.99
    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  14. Colman's Prepared Mustard 3.5 oz
    Colman's Prepared Mustard 3.5 oz
    $3.19
    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
  15. Honeycup Uniquely Sharp Mustard
    Honeycup Uniquely Sharp Mustard
    $5.49
    Add to Wish List Add to Compare
Page
per page
Narrow Your Search
Shopping Options
Category
  • Mustards 57items
Less
Manufacturer
  1. Arbor Hill 2items
  2. Beaverton Foods 6items
  3. Brownwood Farms 3items
  4. Colman's of Norwich 1item
  5. Kozlik's 1item
  6. Lakeshore 3items
  7. Lowensenf 2items
  8. McCormick & Co. 1item
  9. Merle 2items
  10. Nance's 2items
  11. Pommery 5items
  12. Sabatino Tartufi 1item
  13. Sierra Nevada Brewing Co 2items
  14. Stonewall Kitchen 4items
  15. Terrapin Farms 3items
  16. Unilever 3items
  17. Weber's 10items
  18. Woeber's Mustard Co. 3items
  19. World Finer Foods 2items
Less
Cuisine Type (if appl.)
  1. French 2items
Stock
  1. In Stock 47items
  2. Out of Stock 10items
Price
$
-
Condiment/Sauce Type
  1. Horseradish 1item
  2. Mustard 52items
  3. Relish 3items
Country of Origin
  1. Canada 4items
  2. France 6items
  3. Germany 2items
  4. Ireland 1item
  5. United Kingdom 1item
  6. United States 43items
Less
Special Designation (Select no more than 5)
  1. Gluten-Free 2items
  2. Natural Ingredients 3items
  3. No Artificial Flavors 1item
Compare Products
  1. Remove This Item
Compare
Clear All
You have no items to compare.
My Wish List
Last Added Items
  1. Add to Cart
    Remove This Item
Go to Wish List
You have no items in your wish list.